Stories run gamut of human emotions. And English wine's off list
Published:  13 July, 2007

What an extraordinary mix of issues in the latest OLN .

I was dismayed that the normally sensible BMA can seriously think it unwise to suggest food with wine but equally delighted that slammers and shots are getting a thumbs-down.

The test purchasing article made my hackles rise with anger at the injustice we, as independent retailers, have to contend with in respect of our efforts to prevent under-age selling.

However, the wonderful spat between Malcolm Gluck and Tim Atkin was there to lift my spirits, again. I do not often agree with Mr Gluck's views but he does make it clear that he rates wines on a value-for-money basis. Is there any other way? If one is in the position of having to sell the wines one lists, it†is imperative to consider the selling price when tasting and rating choices.

I agree that there are some excellent English wines but they do not stand up to scrutiny when the cost is included in the equation. In this respect English wines rule themselves off my list.

I doubt that this will, in any way, settle the argument but I could not resist sticking my oar in .

Charles Bennett

Hanslope Wines

Hanslope




Site Search

COMMENT

Welcoming the wine rookie

Itís all true. Wine writers loaf around in a state of partial inebriation and partial undress, bitching about having to taste free wine all day and using recondite words like malolactic, terroir and recondite.†

Click for more »
Upcoming events

Polls

Is blended Scotch overshadowed by single malt in retailers?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Don't know

Facebook

Twitter